
If you sift though the dregs of your past, are you going to be proud of what you find? If you don't, is it something you can, or even want to change? The past, deeds done or not done weigh heavily in Nick Horby's newest book. In the end some characters find a different path, a way to move forward toward something redemptive. Others are content to stick with the path they're on, happy to be who they are and have been.
Tucker Crowe is a semi well known musician with one great album, Juliet to his credit. He walks from a men's toilet in Minnesota while on tour and quits music all together. The cause and the events that led up to such a decision are the source of endless speculation by his few, dwindling die hard fans known as Crowologists. Annie's boyfriend, Duncan, is one such Crowologist, perhaps even the world's preeminent, or at least extremely vocal about it. When an acoustic version of the Crowe's great album Juliet, Naked is released, the lives of Tucker, Annie, Duncan, Tucker's four ex-wives and five children all converge.
Other reviews of this book talk about how Hornby gets back to his musical roots with this book. I found that while music is the vehicle, the book is less about music (no top fives here), and more about the notions of fandom, what constitutes art, and how art makes people feel, including the artist themselves. What we find is, according to Hornby, no clear definition of any of the above, and really isn't that how it's supposed to be? How often do we hear, someone declare that they love a song and the person standing next to them replies they feel as though
their ears are bleeding. I had a friend announce to me the other day that they hate Pink Floyd. My response was incredulous. You can hate certain Pink Floyd songs, Money and Time for example, but you can't hate Pink Floyd in its entirety, it's not possible. Alas, it is.
Juliet, Naked is a fast and enjoyable read. The discourse between Tucker and his young son Jackson alone are worthy of more than one out loud laugh.
This book is good for: Beaches and long weekends.